I just love Tom Selleck. He's handsome but he's also charming and funny, which makes him more attractive. Plus I like facial hair on guys. And I adored him in Folks and In & Out.
Sam Elliot...facial hair, great eyes, AWESOME voice. Craggy and masculine looking, IMO. Plus I could listen to him read the phone book.
I like Clooney...and not because he's handsome. (which he definitely is a good looking guy) I like that he's hilarious and sarcastic. When he plays parts like he did in O Brother Where Art Thou? ...he went up a lot on my list of favorite actors.
Sean Connery...from middle age and older. Voice too.
Most actors are considered handsome but I also am attracted to what type of parts they play and how they come across in interviews, etc. Heck Steve Buschemi and John Malkovich are on my list.
And I think Clint Eastwood is a handsome man too. Rugged or craggy or something...
You jump in the saddle,
Hold onto the bridle!
Jump in the line!
Cary Grant. I know he's not considered "flashy" enough by many, but a man with a lot of "flash" like Tom Selleck for some reason makes me suspicious automatically. (And I did watch and like Magnum PI.) But love Cary Grant in the old movies. Good looking, but not TOO good looking. That's exactly the type I like looking at most.