Don't want my dog drinking out of the toilet (or the cat, for that matter).
Don't want the toilet to spray stuff around when I flush (and this is a proven thing).
I don't want to risk anything 'falling in' since I have a shelf of stuff over the toilet (one of those racks that fits over? I've got a little radio and all my towels and stuff and a candle up on the top shelf).
I think there's more plusses to keeping the lid closed when the toilet bowl is not in use than there are plusses to keeping it up (the only thing I can think of for leaving it up is it's a touch more convenient when you've gotta go).
Very few people I know keep the lids of their toilets down all the time. You go into the bathroom, the lid's up, the seat's down. Unless you go in after a guy's been in there. Then sometimes the seat's up, or sometimes the seat and lid are both down.
Is this what you're asking about, OP? When lids aren't customarily left down but the guys put them down? I've sometimes wondered this myself.
Have any guys responded to this thread, which seems directed towards them specifically?
Founder of the People Who Prefer COTH Over FB Clique
People Who Hate to Rush to Kill Wildlife Clique!
"I Sing Silly Songs to My Animals!" Clique
stuff falls into the toilet....not fun having to yank the throne out to find a item lodged in the bowels you have to remove to keep it from clogging up all the time.
Yes, this. My youngest cat is a fat nosy klutz with enough Bengal in him to make him more curious about water than he should be. He already chews my shower liner, I don't need him skinny dipping in my toilet.
The Knotted Pony
Proud and upstanding member of the Women With Attack Tatas Clique
not if you clean it.
Lids down. There's no reason to leave them up, and lots reasons to leave them down. In addition to not wanting to spray fecal matter all over the place every time you flush, surely I'm not the only person who has occasional clutzy moments and accidentally launches the toothbrush or the hairbrush or what have you off into space- if the toilet lid is up, guess where it lands.