They look to be the same model, but the Elite EQ has the microsuede, while the Xtreme is more like the GPA material. Both are perfectly fine for hunters, but I personally prefer the Elite EQ, but it is really up to you!
I have the Xtreme, and other than the finish on the helmet, the harness is leather vs nylon I believe. I love my helmet and get a ton of compliments on it! I prefer the plastic cover to microsuede - so much easier to keep clean and looking good. I was warned that the black helmet scuffs easily, but I have the grey version and am very happy with how it's maintained its good looks.