Except Amigos quality is suspect. The one I bought last year was never waterproof. My horse was wet the first time he got rained on in it (the 2nd or 3rd wearing).
I don't know many other brands that do the attached neck like Rambo. I was a huge fan of Rambos, but have fallen head over heels for the Smartpak turnouts. I also have always loved Shires, especially the Stormcheeta. Those would be my two go to brands. Both DO come with leg straps, but that's easily remedied by taking them off and putting on a tail strap.
I'm a big Rambo fan, but have had very good luck with some Dover products. I have Supreme turnouts which have lasted for years and remain waterproof. Not sure what they offer in hooded products.
You may have some luck finding used Rambos on Craigslist or your local USEA classified site.
Rhino? I bought a Rambo Wug for my horse years ago and was going to buy another for the next horse, but ended up with a Rhino Wug because the shop didn't have his size in the Rambos. I was just as happy with the Rhino as the Rambo - maybe happier because it was a lot less expensive!
I've had four Rhinos. I did buy a Rambo again, but it was barely used and priced lower than the comparable Rhino (there's that money thing again ).
I haven't had any issues with the Amigo with neckrug that I bought this fall. I can't speak to durability yet though.
Yes, I'm not an Amigo fan either. Amanda, which specific Smartpak ones do you like?
I have a "Classic" sheet and the "Deluxe" high neck. Both are very good, but my preference is for the Deluxe. I am considering buying him a second one in heavy. You also get the Deluxe in a regular cut plus a neck rug. I am trying to convince Smartpak to make a neck rug in a no fill version so I can replace the Amigo!
Amigo! Love love love my midweight Amigo. So far has stood up to my geldings rough play and rolling. Has stayed waterproof in pouring rain all day. Mine came with a neck cover but I rarely use it. The fit at the chest is perfect for my wide QH, no other blanket I've found will not rub. Even the new Rambos with the V closure or whatever it is called seem too narrow for him.
ETA: I've owned all 3 lines in the Horseware brand. The Rambo is definitely the best made IMO. If you want something that will wear like iron and has all the "extras" like reflective tape and a 3rd belly surcingle then they are definitely worth the high price tag. I've never had a lot of luck with Rhinos. The first one I got was one of the green plaid ones, worked well until one day it was in shreds, no idea why, my guy was out with one other horse and that horse wasn't a blanket biter. Second Rhino had a front surcingle ripped off after a few months of use. My Amigo is on its second season and looks nearly new.
I've also owned sstack blankets, I HATE them with a passion. Ill fitting, shoulder rubs galore, sheets don't stay waterproof, ripped shoulder gussets, I was pulling my hair out when i used them.
I used to be a fan of the high priced, big name blankets. But then I discovered The Tough One, sold by Chicks Saddlery.
The shape is good, they last as long as any other blanket (except Rambos -- I will admit that Rambo's last longer than I want to own one, but I can't rationalize buying a new blanket when the old one still keeps a horse warm).
And The Tough One makes the best neck covers ever.
I have no financial interest in the brand -- I just fell across it several years ago. And now I am a fan.