I do seem to remember his first foals were consistently very high scoring-so I think you would get a really good looking foal! Not your question I know but I am not sure how old his first crop is so they may be harder to get a read on performance wise.
I think Chicardo also scored high points for his jump and canter.
You might want to post over at the AHHA forum board?
(edited to add...hmm he is little older than I thought-I guess he should have some youngsters out there...not sure how big a book he had in early years?)
I love doing bloodline searches on warmbloods-for-sale, it's a good resource to see several offspring from different breeders and to see how a stud is producing, also it's nice when said stallions offspring all have SOLD by them.
http://warmbloods-for-sale.com/Blood...?Sire=chicardo There are 4 on there. I booked to him late this year as a last resort to a new mare, unfortunately she didn't catch so I will be trying again in 2013, I love Chicardo, unfortunately that also doesn't answer your question but I hope that helps a bit...