I like the fit A LOT better than the Circle Y. At first I wasn't sure about the flatter cantle but after riding in it I didn't mind it at all. I kind of liked it! I didn't ride in it too terribly much as I have a sore on the inside of my leg from another saddle.
And markings, I didnt ride enough for good sweat marks (leg hurt like hell) But the hair lays fairly even overall on her back unlike the other saddle when it not only had a huge dry spot but it also twisted the hair badly.
It's easier to see for sure when it's directly on her back, than when it's on a pad. That said, I think it has more potential than the others in terms of fit. I'd ride in it again when you can get a better sweat mark and if you don't get any dry spots you're probably good to go.