My guy lives in bellboots and has pretty much destroyed them all. Till I bought the petal bell boots. The ONLY thing that stays put, doesn't fall apart and I like that they allow lots more airflow but still protect.
Another rec. for the Professional Choice boots. Initially, I had my doubts. We've had a horse with bar shoes living in the same pair for months now. He used to go through a pair of the Davis velcro boots or the gum rubber pull ons in 2 weeks or less. The PC ones are very tough. They do run super small, however, even if you follow the sizing chart. I just bought a pair for my ISH who doesn't have super big feet and the XXL just fit.