The Chronicle of the Horse
MagazineNewsHorse SportsHorse CareCOTH StoreVoicesThe Chronicle UntackedMarketplaceDates & Results
 
Results 1 to 15 of 15
  1. #1
    Join Date
    Aug. 14, 2000
    Location
    Clarksdale, MS--the golden buckle on the cotton belt
    Posts
    17,550

    Default Comment on eventing commentary

    Did anyone else feel that somebody hadn't done enough research for interesting tidbits to fill in dead spaces.

    I was thinking that it was never mentioned that Ingrid Klimke not only rides in eventing but that she also rides GP dressage; or that her father started out as an eventer; or that both her and Dibo's horses were from the same breeding program and were the same age. Or who were coaching the teams, or...

    Sometimes some of the background and commentary seemed so lacking in true expertise.

    I know that Melanie Smith is a jumper person, but she can only work with what the research department provides, and they just didn't provide enough.
    "I'm a lumberjack, and I'm okay."
    Thread killer Extraordinaire



  2. #2
    Join Date
    Feb. 9, 2004
    Location
    Sunny CA
    Posts
    4,593

    Default

    IMHO why have a SJ person do the commentary? Where is Jim W when we need him? Also why sit in NY? I love Melanie but her comments were repetitive and wearing. If she said one more time the jumps were so delicate I was going to scream! Also she kept saying that a horse didn't touch a thing right as they were showing said horse with a rail jumping around in the cups!

    Needless to say I appreciate any coverage us horsey types can get but with the time not many in the world got to see it. Most people don't even think they are broadcasting any Equestrian (at least on the West Coast where most are still working at 3:00!)
    Steph

    http://community.webshots.com/user/stephanne014

    Rerider/Haydunker Clique

    RIP Barbaro, you were my hero!



  3. #3
    Join Date
    Mar. 20, 2003
    Location
    Ontario, Canada
    Posts
    589

    Default

    The Canadian commentaries are great! Giving lots of tidbits of information and explaining things quite well for non-horsey viewers.
    "Show me your horse and I will tell you who you are."
    "Pocket Aces" Vegas
    "Sergeant Pepper" Pepper



  4. #4
    Join Date
    Dec. 25, 2005
    Posts
    1,844

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Gunnar View Post
    IMHO why have a SJ person do the commentary? Where is Jim W when we need him?
    I agree. There are plenty of eventers out there who would have had a lot more information to give, especially for the cross-country portion. I don't think she was bad for the SJ, but XC left a lot to be desired.



  5. #5
    Join Date
    Jun. 20, 2008
    Posts
    3,241

    Default

    I think it was during the X-country our folks in NYC were talking about Philip riding for Australia and couldn't get it that the US had gotten this phenomenal rider who is now riding for USA ! "oh that's right that's right, he got he is now riding for US - I would expect that from nearly every other sports commentator but not someone who is involved w/ showjumping and all of that.

    It would also be nice if the regular commentators would every once in awhile announce other medal winners besides Michael Phelps and the battle between the US and Chinese gymnasts

    and whoever made the comment about womens/mens vollyball was right on



  6. #6
    Join Date
    Sep. 6, 1999
    Location
    Phoenix, AZ
    Posts
    5,215

    Default

    Yeah, while generally I like Melanie but this time, there must have been some real technical difficulties with being in NYC.
    If she said one more time about the dressage scoring... "Oh well they seem to be scoring higher now in the afternoon" or "In the morning they were scoring lower and now they seem to be more lenient" I thought I was going to shoot her! Like it's subjective or something.
    And then she totally didn't comment on the striding or anything in sj. I thought for sure she would nail that part. Like when the German took those long ones and still went clear. She should have been right there about that and how lucky he was.
    I miss Jimmy! Or Kerry Miliken did Rolex online and did a fabulous job.



  7. #7
    Join Date
    Nov. 23, 1999
    Location
    South Coast Plaza
    Posts
    20,249

    Default

    I do not know why they continue to hire her as a commentator. Then again, has anyone seen the recent Aachen classes on Animal Planet? No Emmys there either.
    EDDIE WOULD GO



  8. #8
    Join Date
    Jun. 29, 2004
    Posts
    10,128

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by vineyridge View Post
    I know that Melanie Smith is a jumper person, but she can only work with what the research department provides, and they just didn't provide enough.
    Don't blame it on the research department, many of us "nobodies" on the BB have a wealth of background information on many of these horses and riders, just because of our interest in horses. If anything she should know a lot more than we do. I am not attacking her personally, I just think she is not at all good as a commentator.



  9. #9
    Join Date
    Oct. 7, 2006
    Location
    on and off the bit
    Posts
    3,804

    Default

    Personally, I'd enjoy a bit of "dead air" now and again. I get headaches from the constant commentary.
    I'd prefer to just get to watch the rides.

    That said, I would love to know what the volleyball comment was!
    Founder of the People Who Prefer COTH Over FB Clique
    People Who Hate to Rush to Kill Wildlife Clique!
    "I Sing Silly Songs to My Animals!" Clique



  10. #10
    Join Date
    Feb. 8, 2008
    Posts
    196

    Default

    Ugg, my husband and I were both wishing Melanie would just be quiet every once in a while. She repeated herself a lot and I felt like she used a lot of jargon that the average viewer wouldn't understand.

    When you watch swimming or gymnastics, the commentators will teach you about the sport. I now know it's bad to bend your elbows on the high bar, or staying sideways while turning underwater is faster. Why can't they do that with horses? Explain what a deep spot is and how that makes dropping a rail more likely - that would be such an easy graphic to do! Or show how if a rider gets way ahead of the horse that can cause a rail, again, fairly easy to show in slow-mo.



  11. #11
    Join Date
    Nov. 20, 2007
    Posts
    38

    Default

    The guy with Melanie is worse, I guess he is a race commentator or something, but it cracked me up when he said "looks to be going a little crooked there" when the horse was doing shoulder-in down the center line. Anyone else catch that? And how many times can he say "equestrian" in one sentence because he has no other horsey vocabulary to use?



  12. #12
    Join Date
    Mar. 22, 2005
    Location
    Where it is perpetually winter
    Posts
    4,761

    Default

    Am I the only one who watches all of the equestrian stuff muted? I can't stand some of the commentary.



  13. #13
    Join Date
    Mar. 15, 2007
    Location
    SE PA
    Posts
    1,677

    Default

    I thought Kerry Miliken did a good job at Rolex. It's shame they didn't ask her.
    ** I LOVE PUIKA & SHELLA FAN CLUB*** member
    Quote Originally Posted by 2DogsFarm View Post
    Good job R&G!
    You may now add Horsesaver Extraordinaire to your resume



  14. #14
    Join Date
    Jul. 20, 2003
    Location
    San Antonio, TX
    Posts
    2,221

    Default

    One thing Melanie said that sent me over the edge: during eventing dressage, after (I think) Lucinda Fredericks' ride, she kept saying how the judge would be comparing all the rest of the rides to that one. Uh, no! Each dressage ride is scored on its own merit and how it measures up to official standards, not how it compares to someone else's ride!
    Jonah 4:4: And the Lord said, "Do you do well to be angry?"

    With every day that passes, college football season gets that much closer!



  15. #15
    Join Date
    Dec. 1, 1999
    Location
    flyover country
    Posts
    1,738

    Default Melanie

    They have used her for years, I think because she is a Gold Medallist. Her commentary is insulting because I think she went thru Pony Club and should have a rudimentary knowlege of Dressage and eventing. She covered I think Barcelona when there was a long hold. I think one of the US riders were on course and dismounted. She worried that he/she would be dqed. These two do enough horse stuff that THEY SHOULD DO THEIR OWN RESEARCH!!! NO EXCUSE! She has been around way long enough. I agreee, listen with sound down.
    Another killer of threads



Similar Threads

  1. Commentary by Chris Hector - enjoy
    By Oakstable in forum Sport Horse Breeding
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: Dec. 24, 2011, 03:12 PM
  2. Canter Commentary, Please
    By Wellspotted in forum Dressage
    Replies: 12
    Last Post: Aug. 13, 2008, 01:07 PM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •