PDA

View Full Version : Help me solve a mystery...


Mac123
Dec. 31, 2009, 04:18 PM
I have a horse that has something wrong with it and we cannot figure out what it is. ANY thoughts are appreciated!!!

Original presentation: Horse has had two days off (due to a muscle spasm in my back). He had been going fabulously. First ride back was argumentative and quick. I originally thought he was fresh but began to realize he wasn't right and must be sore somewhere.

He was tight through the back, a bit quick, and snarky when using the right rein. Over fences, did not push off the ground and was weak on takeoff. Toward the end of the ride he began bucking or kicking out when I used the right rein or during the left canter transition.

Day two: Very backsore, felt NQR at all under tack. "Offness" was moving around - felt it up front and behind. Pulled the saddle and he was very backsore.

Day three: Realized the left front frog had considerable thrush and was very sore through the frog and heel.

I gave him about a week off and while he looked better on the longe line, he was still presenting under saddle. Below is a total list of symptoms, listed in order of thought as they spring to mind.


Symptoms:

Backsore - more towards the back of where the saddle lies (last thoracic, first lumbar) but is sore all through the saddle area.
Funny on the right hind
Hot stifle and hock points
Flexes positive on each hock ONLY on the outside of a turn - he is sound on the straightaways immediately after the flexion and only positive through the turn on the outside hind
Thrush in left front frog - considerably sore in the frog and heal bulbs
Funny on left front
Bucking through transitions and after landing after low fences
Worse when weightbearing - the heavier the rider, the worse it is
Will not connect over the back - there is no continuation of energy. He is quick tempoed, doesn't use his back, and does not stretch out and down. No elasticity.
Snarky
Generally bodysore
Cannot do a right-left leadchange under saddle or at liberty. He will swap up front but not behind. He has difficulty with undersaddle changes, but has always been able to do them at liberty with ease.


With time off, the backsoreness IMPROVES, the hock and stifle points stay mostly the same.

The saddle fits very well, and while switching to a saddle that has a greater weight-bearing surface did make him more comfortable, he was still bucking through the transitions and jumping. Every saddle pad known to mankind has been tried with no results.

My inclination is that the backsoreness is secondary because it is the first thing to improve with time off but comes back whenever he is ridden. If the backsoreness was primary, it wouldn't improve at all. And no saddle or pad combination make him comfortable.

No heat, no swelling, no identifiable gimp.

I had a vet look at him on Monday who does chiro/acupuncture. She was not able to find anything other than the hot hock/stifle points, the strange flexion result, and that his pelvis and lumbosacral were out of place. She adjusted him and injected the hock points with B12 and gave me a chinese herb (Body Sore) for his body soreness.

He looked great afterwards, but immediately began presenting under saddle.

I am wondering if the sore thrushy left front could cause all of this....if he's holding himself funky to protect that it could cause soreness through the right hind (compensatory) and through the back.

This all happened all of the sudden. He was going great, had two days off, and all the sudden is like this. The vet agreed with my original assessment that he may have gotten cast or fallen in the paddock triggering something....but this doesn't make sense as it is clearly related to being ridden.

I am going crazy and want to keep my hair...any thoughts???

ETA - horse is a 7 year old TB schooling 3'9-4' in grids and 3' to 3'3 courses. Normally relaxed, quiet, excellent flatwork, lovely, powerful jump. Daily turnout in small paddock (not ideal, I know, but it is what it is). Safe choice and lots of hay. No prior lamenesses or issues other than a bad case of thrush behind a couple months ago that left him sore as well.

rcloisonne
Dec. 31, 2009, 04:57 PM
ETA - horse is a 7 year old TB schooling 3'9-4' in grids and 3' to 3'3 courses. Normally relaxed, quiet, excellent flatwork, lovely, powerful jump. Daily turnout in small paddock (not ideal, I know, but it is what it is). Safe choice and lots of hay. No prior lamenesses or issues other than a bad case of thrush behind a couple months ago that left him sore as well.
What are you doing for the thrush? Is your farrier involved?

WishIWereRiding
Dec. 31, 2009, 06:08 PM
I posted on your other thread.

caballus
Dec. 31, 2009, 06:18 PM
Check the hind hooves for balance and levelness. Go here:
http://www.barefoottrim.com/2007/balance/balance.htm for some landmarks to follow and things you can look at to see if the hooves are correctly trimmed. (yes, even if shod - the hooves have to be trimmed correctly.)

Mac123
Dec. 31, 2009, 07:03 PM
Yes, the farrier is involved.

I use a combination of sole paint (formaldehyde, iodine), cow mastitis meds, and rubbing alcohol for the thrush. Not used all at one time, I rotate.

The sole paint wasn't doing much, so I've switched to the rubbing alcohol (which worked well the last time he got a bad case of thrush).

It doesn't appear awful in looks, but it's created a soft mushy frog which is sensitive and the bulbs are also mushy and sore.

Our weather has been atrocious - cool, WET, and humid - OR frozen - giving an apt environment for this to set in...Even the shavings are holding moisture, so I'm debating about packing the foot and wrapping it but know that the wrap will retain moisture too - thoughts on which is the better of two evils?

Cab - the feet are well balanced, thanks, and this wouldn't have happened in two days if it was a foot balance issue. But even to the "natural" standards, he's balanced. Even though he's shod.

Fharoah
Dec. 31, 2009, 08:31 PM
I would think that back pain is often secondary. If you have acess to a good clinic get a bone scan. This horse may have multiple sources of discomfort. If you can get on and ride him lightly a week before the scan to bring out the hot spots. Then you can formulate a plan! Otherwise I would really look at feet, pastern and hocks. Allot of lower limb lameness makes the horse tight up higher.

Best Wishes!

Auburn
Jan. 1, 2010, 10:34 AM
Maybe I mis-read your post, but why were you jumping a horse that you had already determined to be back sore and NQR?

Horses usually do not have drastic changes of behavior for no reason.

Changes in the hocks can cause the horses' back to tighten up and become sore. Since you found that the stifles and hocks were hot, did your Vet/Chiro take any x-rays of them?

If there is something going on in the hocks, then your Vet may need to start injections to make him more comfortable.

Also, I have read about kissing spine on this BB, but do not know much about it. You could ask your Vet about that and/or EPM.

I hope that you find a way to make your boy more comfortable soon.

Mac123
Jan. 1, 2010, 12:57 PM
Thanks for everyone's thoughts.

Auburn, our thinking is that changes in hocks and stifles don't occur overnight unless it is an acute injury. With no heat/swelling, acute injury is unlikely. I'm not beyond injecting hocks, but I never do so unless I am sure that is a specific problem. Not to mention, he flexed negative until he was going through a turn. Hocks and stifle soreness usually presents immediately, with the worst steps being their first.

We only jumped two tiny (2ft) verticals used diagnostically. At some point with a NQR horse you have to push things to find a source. Sometimes jumping can help relieve back soreness as it stretches the topline. It's obviously not the case here - which is another piece of the puzzle we now have.