PDA

View Full Version : Between Rounds With Denny Emerson From The Chronicle


katnetzler
Nov. 21, 2008, 09:16 AM
As a service to our online equine community, the Chronicle is pleased to offer our weekly Between Rounds columns for free on the COTH Forums.

The Training Three-Day Event Is Hanging On By A Toenail
November 21, 2008 Issue

Our columnist believes that if we want the classic three-day to survive, we must support its educational objectives at all levels.

It doesn’t take long for solidly established sets of skills to be forgotten once they’re abandoned from general usage. In 1925, every farm kid in America knew how to stack loose hay into a barn. Running the length of the ridgepole in our old barn in Strafford, Vt., is a track, hanging from which are some large hooks, or tines. If I had to back a team of horses hitched to a wagon piled with loose hay into my barn, and use those hay hooks to unload the wagon, I’d be lost at sea!

Last summer, I was the starter for phase A, the first roads and tracks, at the Green Mountain Horse Association Training Level Three-Day Event in South Woodstock, Vt. Many of the riders were equally unsure and nervous about how to compete in a full three-day event, and yet the classic three-day event was largely abandoned only five or six years earlier, not 80 years ago like my hay hooks.

We’re losing basic horsemanship skills very rapidly in the United States, and one way to preserve them in eventing, at least, is to ensure that some level of the classic three-day event survives.

Virtually all of the major international riders of this era grew up riding in the classic three-day. They learned how to get horses fit, how to pace themselves trotting on phases A and C, how to pace themselves at speed galloping over the steeplechase fences on phase B, and how to use the 10-minute vet box hold before phase D, cross-country, to help their horses recover. They learned how to manage their horses after the long day of what used to be called, “speed and endurance,” and they learned how to prepare their horses for the challenge of the trot up for the veterinary inspection on the morning of show jumping.

In another 10 or 20 years as eventing is now headed, we’ll have a whole generation of coaches, trainers and riders who will have never had to acquire these skills, and will be as ignorant of their usage as I am about how to stack loose hay.

Fighting against the loss of all this knowledge, determined to preserve it for the next generation of eventers, are a handful of event organizers and supporters of the training level three-day event.

Cindy DePorter told me that about six years ago, as the three-day event was being abandoned, Area II chairman, D.C. McBroom, asked her to find an organizer willing to run a training level three-day. Gretchen and Robert Butts, owners of Waredaca Farm in Unity, Md., offered the use of the farm if the Area II Adult Riders would help to run the event.

The Waredaca success story is the result of that initial contact.

“Waredaca does the courses, builds the jumps, hires the officials, and takes in the entry fees,” said Cindy, “and the adult riders staff the event, provide super prizes down to 10th place, and sponsor all kinds of course walks and educational seminars on every aspect of how to take part in a three-day event.”

Meanwhile, in 2005, Joe Silva, then executive director of GMHA, believed that the training three-day was a perfect addition to the services provided under GMHA’s educational mission, a kind of adjunct for adults to what GMHA’s long-standing Pony Club clinics were to children.

That 2005 event ran at a financial loss to GMHA, so Joe and his committee decided to run every other year, skipping 2006. Then in 2007, a rider donated $5,000 to the event, “because I’ve always wanted to ride in a three-day, and I want there to be one when my horse and I are ready.”

GMHA ran the training level three-day again in 2007 and ‘08, but although it was an enormous amount of work for GMHA, it still barely broke even. Which leads to now.

In Area I, Cindy Strate is the Adult Rider Coordinator, and, inspired by Waredaca, she’s decided to try to do for the GMHA event what the Area II adults have done for Waredaca.

Cindy is working with Jon Woodhull, the current GMHA director, and they have a dozen initiatives going, ranging from local Area I fund raising, creating publicity and “buzz,” seeking trophies and prizes, contacting qualified riders, and establishing educational seminars to familiarize riders with what to expect and prepare for. There are similar “Support The Three-Day” initiatives currently going on in other USEA Areas as well, but these are the two I know about.

This brings the sport of eventing, one little segment of it at least, right back to its roots, in two ways.

First, the three-day event, with its emphasis on speed, stamina, endurance, conditioning and recovery is the direct link with our cavalry past, something that our new short format has mainly abandoned. But there’s a more direct link with a more recent past, the past 50 years or so, which only a few of us now remember.

In the late ’50s through the ’60s, the survival of eventing in the United States was by no means assured. It was hanging on by its toenails when I first evented at GMHA in 1962 (in a full preliminary level three-day event, no less). There were only three events in Area I.

In fact, the local riders who competed in the event were the same people who built the cross-country course up at Lloyd and Stella Reeves’ Flying Heels Farm. One day I specifically remember the only three workers on that hill were Dr. H.L.M. Van Schaik, Tad Coffin and myself. A big thunderstorm rolled in, and I was holding a big iron prybar. “Denny,” said Mr. Van Schaik, “maybe you should put down that iron bar!”

Back in the ’60s, if we wanted the sport of eventing to survive, we had to personally make that happen. Now, nearly 50 years later, we find ourselves in exactly the same situation with the classic format.

Denny Emerson

Denny Emerson rode on the 1974 World Championship gold-medal eventing team. He served as the U.S. Eventing Association president twice and won the USEA Wofford Cup for his lifetime dedication to eventing. At his Tamarack Hill Farm in South Strafford, Vt., and Southern Pines, N.C., he trains horses and riders and stands stallions. An original Between Rounds contributor, Emerson began writing his column in 1989.

CookiePony
Nov. 21, 2008, 09:44 AM
I am really glad to see this article and it is very well-argued. We need the T3DE!

One of those efforts in other areas besides I and II is a small group of us in Area III who are trying to promote and educate. We got VTO Saddlery to donate prizes (nice wool embroidered coolers) to the recent Ocala T3DE and we have made a new website: www.trainingthreeday.com .

FLeckenAwesome
Nov. 21, 2008, 12:42 PM
and we're working on other plans too :) Additional clinics throughout the year to help inspire and educate people BEFORE the T3D so that people can get motivated and prepared, promotion of the T3D, and other exciting things :)

poltroon
Nov. 21, 2008, 01:11 PM
I think the training 3dE is wonderful. I'm sad I no longer have a horse going training, but maybe some day again.

BaroquePony
Nov. 21, 2008, 06:18 PM
Great 'sticky note' thread.

ksbadger
Nov. 21, 2008, 09:10 PM
The problem seems to be that, despite all the hype (with all due respect to Denny), there just isn't the real demand for the T3D. Two event venues in Area IV tried to put one on this year - one had a single taker and thus didn't run - the other had a grand total of four entrants and did run as it was in conjunction with their normal HT. Both these were after relatvely well advertized & supported T3D training sessions.

My opinion is that very few non-professional riders have enough time to get their horses (or themselves) sufficiently fit for any level above Novice - viz the number of "last third" XC falls at Training and above. This would appear to be especilly true for JR/YR with the insane amount of extra-curricular activities heaped on the average American high schooler.

denny
Nov. 22, 2008, 06:46 AM
It may well prove that all forms of the classic 3-day are headed for extinction. Certainly they are if this generation won`t fight for them.

What does that mean for the future?

Think of this:
All graduates of the normal 4 year degree programs of normal colleges are taught by professors who got their 4 year degrees, and then went on to several more years of graduate school for advanced degrees.

Now assume that all advanced degree programs are suddenly abolished.

For some years there would be little fallout in the quality of undergrad education, because the professors would still be those with advanced degrees.

But years slide by, the older professors retire, and who replaces them?

New professors without advanced degrees.

And then begins the gradual diminuation of taught skills and knowledge.

Look at the huge fuss over the watchlist, and the comparative lack of interest in this 3-day issue. If people would get educated, they wouldn`t have to fear getting reported, but the fact is, education is hard, and people so often avoid getting much of it!

canyonoak
Nov. 22, 2008, 12:23 PM
http://www.galwaydowns.com/eventing.html

Galway Downs held its TENTH annual 3DE and Horse Trials a few weekends ago.

Fingers crossed the sport stays alive and well in California!

tommygirl
Nov. 22, 2008, 05:37 PM
... And then begins the gradual diminuation of taught skills and knowledge.

Look at the huge fuss over the watchlist, and the comparative lack of interest in this 3-day issue. If people would get educated, they wouldn`t have to fear getting reported, but the fact is, education is hard, and people so often avoid getting much of it!

When I first decided that I wanted to event (I was 9 yrs old), I knew that it was an elite sport where ONLY the most dedicated and determined people could make the upper levels, despite their financial situation. It was a time when someone could take any breed of horse and compete, as long as that horse had heart. You could do it on a shoe string, camp at the shows, use one bad saddle, braid badly, and go home with a ton of pride knowing you were part of something special. I believe all these things still exist, I just think they are being covered up with fancy trailers, trucks, saddles professionally fitted (even if there is no need), curtains for tack stalls (yuck!), expensive boots, really ugly socks, $400+ blankets and big $$$ horses.

The people who are really dedicated need to step up, speak up and save the 3-Day! Myself included. We need to STOP entering the short format classes and quit focusing on prize money. We all wanted the sport to get "popular". It did. Now we pay by loosing our sport - otherwise know as the "Classic" format.

Carried Away
Nov. 22, 2008, 06:36 PM
Well said, Tommygirl! I agree 100%, and can also remember the "old days" (not so long ago) when it was more about the partnership with your horse than what kind of saddle/helmet/boots/etc. you were riding in. I think as our country moves further and further into the need for "things", we forget about why we started eventing in the first place. We need to stick together and stay focused on what our sport means to each of us. This means volunteering, sharing knowledge, and encouraging our fellow competitors to see the sport's true meaning.

RunForIt
Nov. 22, 2008, 06:49 PM
Denny, you're an educator so I know you're on to something here...

As a reading and mathematics teacher I design rubrics that tell kids and parents what the children are going to learn in the next six weeks AND the levels and indicators that will tell them where they currently are demonstrating proficiency when I (and more importantly, THEY) assess work, skills, strategies, and thinking. I TEACH TO THIS ASSESSMENT - the kids TRAIN to this ASSESSMENT.

Denny, as you began your article, it hit me what the T3DE is really worth - a training evaluation with clear connections between each subtest. That does NOT exist in the horse trials 3-day events of short format eventing.

Every good assessment informs my instruction - the long format is a true evaluation of training, riding skill, and horse'manship (the apostrophe is on purpose being female :D ). I now have my road map. As usual, thanks!

Piney Woods
Nov. 22, 2008, 11:44 PM
Denny. Thank you for continuing to bring this to the forefront. I personally think you are correct in your assessment of the 3DE as an important step in the training of an event horse and rider team. In order to complete a Preliminary 3DE, I feel I learned more than competing at Intermediate and will be forever glad that I got to have that experience.

imapepper
Nov. 26, 2008, 10:55 AM
I think that to help this cause, it would help to have clinics in each area to help prepare for the T3D. I really think that there is alot of interest in doing one but people need to know how to prepare. For example, if a venue around here held a clinic about how to ride the steeplechase portion or did a conditioning clinic, I think people would go.

RunForIt
Nov. 26, 2008, 11:04 AM
I think that to help this cause, it would help to have clinics in each area to help prepare for the T3D. I really think that there is alot of interest in doing one but people need to know how to prepare. For example, if a venue around here held a clinic about how to ride the steeplechase portion or did a conditioning clinic, I think people would go.

PM CookiePony. She can elaborate on some plans in the works for just those kind of clinics all over Area III.

Thanks to Ruthie Harbison bringing Moet to the Ocala T3DE, more pros may join in the fun and the rewards in a better event horse. Go to the Ocala Requirements thread and read Ruthie's post if you haven't done so already...then give it to your trainer to read! :D :cool:

riva1
Nov. 26, 2008, 07:06 PM
What a motivating article Denny. Very well said with a great analogy. I only hope that I can qualify for a T3D while they are still running. I hope there are a lot of greenbeans out there that feel the way I do...

riderboy
Dec. 1, 2008, 08:50 AM
I would love to do a training 3 day someday. That is a real dream.

gully's pilot
Dec. 2, 2008, 07:50 AM
Denny--

My goal for 2009 is to compete in a T3D. I was pretty excited to get my Omnibus yesterday--and now I'm not sure if I'll be able to do one after all. I've got a surgeon for a husband, and two kids at home; I usually compete 3-4 times a year, and have to plan my competitions carefully around my husband's call schedule and our family activities. (I'm not in any way complaining about this--my husband is enormously supportive (not to mention having a job which makes it easy for me to slack off mine), and my kids aren't over-involved in activities, but we take family vacations and my husband has some fun activities for himself, too.) I live on the borders of Areas 2, 3, and 8; technically I'm in area 3 but I usually show in 2 or 8. My choices for the T3D are the early Ocala (too early, I'll never be ready); Ohio over the fourth of July (out, as we do a big traditional Fourth of July party on our farm each year); Waradeca, or the November Ocala. Both Waradeca and Ocala are 10-12 hour hauls for me, so that adds a long day on each side of the trip--It's not likely I'd be able to finish up Sunday afternoon and come straight home. So, a week gone each time. Waradeca happens to be when my husband already has a medical conference scheduled that he wants me to attend with him; Ocala week, he's on call. It may be possible that I can leave when he's on call, but that's tricky--if he gets called out in the middle of the night, and stays out, then he's stuck trying to find a way to get the children to school while coping with someone's medical crisis. (Neither child is of the age to drive.) I could say I don't want to go to the conference--or maybe I can get Bart's mom to come stay while I go to Ocala. But either is going to be pretty difficult.

What I'm saying is--at length and perhaps not very coherently--is that if there were MORE T3Ds, or if they'd put one back at Kentucky, I'd be able to go more easily, and would be at one in a heartbeat.

But truthfully I'm still holding out for Ocala.....

tx3dayeventer
Dec. 2, 2008, 10:25 AM
I think that to help this cause, it would help to have clinics in each area to help prepare for the T3D. I really think that there is alot of interest in doing one but people need to know how to prepare. For example, if a venue around here held a clinic about how to ride the steeplechase portion or did a conditioning clinic, I think people would go.

FWIW, I would more than happy to help "teach" at said clinic if it happened in Area V. I am not a BNT/BNR by any means but I have done 8 or 10 long formats from the T3DE level on up. Maybe Christie @ Greenwood or Sam @ Meadow Creek would "host" said clinic??

Kairoshorses
Dec. 2, 2008, 12:12 PM
FWIW, I would more than happy to help "teach" at said clinic if it happened in Area V. I am not a BNT/BNR by any means but I have done 8 or 10 long formats from the T3DE level on up. Maybe Christie @ Greenwood or Sam @ Meadow Creek would "host" said clinic??


I would come in a heartbeat. Put the idea in their heads, please!!

Kairoshorses
Dec. 2, 2008, 12:40 PM
Think of this:
All graduates of the normal 4 year degree programs of normal colleges are taught by professors who got their 4 year degrees, and then went on to several more years of graduate school for advanced degrees.

Now assume that all advanced degree programs are suddenly abolished.

For some years there would be little fallout in the quality of undergrad education, because the professors would still be those with advanced degrees.

But years slide by, the older professors retire, and who replaces them?

New professors without advanced degrees.

And then begins the gradual diminuation of taught skills and knowledge.


Denny, I want to problematize AND agree with what you say above. I think I like the medaphor, but it's also much, much more complex (as is our situation in eventing).

Many undergrad classes in larger universities are taught by graduate students. They're working on advanced degrees, but they haven't completed them. As someone who used to direct a first year composition program, I can tell you that some of the Teaching Assistants (TAs) could write fairly well, but they couldn't tell you HOW or WHY. Nor, alas, could very many of them explaine the fundamentals of grammar, let alone teach them. While I think that's hugely problematic, I also think that some of them did a fine job teaching writing. It's just that if I had my 'druthers, I'd pick and choose who got to teach. Trouble is, I didn't get to do that.

Four year degrees and advanced degrees vary WIDELY. Many of these grad students I knew DID get advanced degrees, and they STILL don't know the fundamentals of grammar and rhetoric. And guess what? They are the professors who teach writing in the smaller universities. So, just like with eventing, achieving certain things (wins, degrees) doesn't necessarily mean that someone is good.

Is that the end of the world? No. In education, some of these folks have a true passion for what they do (often literature or creative writing), and they know THAT field, and are able to instill excellent information/knoweldge in their students. But they tend to be really focused, and they still don't know grammar and rhetoric. So the students who need these things won't get them. The same thing happens in eventing.

It makes me think of Jimmy Wofford's trope that we shouldn't JUST be doing eventing; we should also be galloping racehorses, training with dressage riders, doing hunter/jumper shows and point-to-ponts. I DO think that eventers are the rhetoricians of the world; they can go to any field, analyze the audience, purpose, and mode, then by analyzing it according to their own expertise, they can master it--in part, because they see the relationships and can build on the basics.

I guess what I'm saying is this: I'm not sure advanced degrees are all that, just as I'm not sure that today's and future eventers are lacking. Professors are GREAT in terms of being an "expert" in a very, very focused area, and I fear that's where we're headed. But having a broad range of skills and being able to analyze goals, purposes, audiences, and so forth, then being able to build on that relational analysis, might be a better way to go. I know too many professors who are brilliant at one thing, and terribly ditzy at everything else.

So maybe we should be doing more 4-H and pony club type education. Maybe we should encourage learning outside eventing. I DO like what Denis said in his column--that too many folks are competing against each other/for ribbons instead of competing with the standards of the level they're in. RunForIt is dead right, but it's not what happens in this era of high stakes testing: We teach to the test, so kids can pass the test, then they can forget everything. They don't really learn. We need to buck that system for sure, and teach folks how to learn--by building on skills and seeing HOW and WHY they relate, and how and why they can be situated and changed given another context.

ksbadger
Dec. 3, 2008, 10:57 PM
FWIW, I would more than happy to help "teach" at said clinic if it happened in Area V. I am not a BNT/BNR by any means but I have done 8 or 10 long formats from the T3DE level on up. Maybe Christie @ Greenwood or Sam @ Meadow Creek would "host" said clinic??

Another possibility is David Harris at Woodlands in Edmond, OK and the OKEventers, who have been doing stirling work encouraging our sport despite not now having a Recognized event in their state. A couple of years back David built some steeplechase fences so a local rider could get some practice in before her first long format. I'm sure there would be riders from southernmost part of Area IV (like Badger or Abrownhorse) who would also be interested. John Staples has also run a very popular T3D clinic here in Wichita and, if there's enough support, a local organizer has said he would run one this year in conjunction with his usual Summer HT.

[Just because I'm not convinced about the economic aspects of the T3D, it doesn't mean I don't fully appreciate the underlying sound training in horsemanship to be had.]

Jeannette, formerly ponygyrl
Dec. 4, 2008, 10:03 AM
I think that to help this cause, it would help to have clinics in each area to help prepare for the T3D. I really think that there is alot of interest in doing one but people need to know how to prepare. For example, if a venue around here held a clinic about how to ride the steeplechase portion or did a conditioning clinic, I think people would go.

I can't vouch for all the T3D's, but I know Waredaca is set up with time and coaching to get to practice a couple steeplechase jumps, and there are dinnertime educational clinics on what happens in the 10 minute box and such.

Certainly riders needed to prep a bit beforehand - finding out what goes in a 10 minute box for instance, and having spare horse shoes fitted to your horse in it, for instance, in addition to having the horse fit enough - but for riders who have successfully completed a couple training level events clean, a T3D is a very attainable next step. Don't be put off by not having access to a prep clinic! Certainly don't let that be your excuse for not entering. "Things we must learn before doing, we only learn by doing them" says Denny quoting Aristotle.